Separated by a Past Life: Retro Couple #1

This is the first in what I hope is a recurring new feature on Go Retro: the retro separated at birth (or separated by a past life) couple. I'll be pairing up a famous person of today with their retro lookalike. Believe me, I've found quite a few couples. This is gonna be fun!

So here is the first. I was watching PBS' old Anne of Green Gables series from the 1980s when it suddenly occured to me that Anne Shirley looked remarkably like Clay Aiken! Big bro and little sis...or maybe Clay wants to play Anne next after his Spamalot gig is over. He's been growing his hair long enough to braid.